| Platinum | Madison Street Antiques |
| Platinum | Pedigo's Madison Street Antiques |
| Gold | City Thrift |
| Silver | Southern Kentucky Flea Market |
| Bronze | Shady Pines Vintage Market |
| Top Pick | Clothes Mentor |
| Top Pick | Goodwill Stores |
| Top Pick | Habitat for Humanity ReStore |
| Top Pick | Warehouse 41 Vintage Market |
| Top Pick | Willow & Thrift |