| Platinum | Caprigios Pizza |
| Gold | Luigi's Pizza |
| Silver | Marco's Pizza |
| Bronze | Pizza Artista |
| Top Pick | Camacho's Famous |
| Top Pick | Chris' Pizza Village |
| Top Pick | Four Brothers Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hunt Brothers Pizza |
| Top Pick | Michael's Pizza, Inc |
| Top Pick | Woodys Pizza |
| Strawberry Alley Ale Works |